The temperature levels in the clouds are indeed milder, theres nowhere near sufficient water to support life, and most of whats present is in droplets that are mainly made up of sulfuric acid.
The latter 2 are relevant since Venus is thought to be a very dry world, and its clouds are generated not by condensed water but rather by the existence of sulfuric acid droplets that would contain some water.
Scientists quantify the amount of readily available water through a step called the water activity. In simple conditions like a humid environment, this is the exact same as the relative humidity– the amount of water present versus the optimum amount at that temperature level and pressure. If you presume that Venusian life might have developed techniques of pulling water out of the sparse environment, then the sulfuric acid ends up being a huge problem.

What about Earth and Jupiter?
Earths upper environment is also most likely to be too dry to support life, but the relative humidity of its lower atmosphere (the troposphere) can differ anywhere from no percent to 100 percent. The majority of clouds in the troposphere, nevertheless, will have a water activity thats compatible with life, which follows findings that a variety of microorganisms most likely make it through the trips through the clouds that some of them wind up taking.
The oddest finding comes from an appearance at Jupiter, which had been gone to by a probe that was dropped off throughout the Galileo objective. The probe occurred to fall through a dry area of the giant planets environment, however we understand that different cloud bands can vary in their structure, and a few of them are most likely rather wet. Ammonia is a making complex presence however is primarily present at altitudes above those where temperatures are within the range compatible with life
While there are a great deal of unpredictabilities, the overall conclusion is that theres likely to be adequate water around to support life at elevations where the temperatures would vary from -30 º to
10º C. Thats life.
The scientists note that this same method ought to assist us check out high-altitude life as we start to get details on the environments of exoplanets. It wont tell us anything about surface area conditions, nevertheless (although a few of those might most likely be presumed from other data). “To be able to determine potential habitability based on that personally excites me,” Hallsworth stated.
The other notable thing here is that this applies to life as we understand it: water-based, with comprehensive usage of hydrocarbons and both hydrophobic and hydrophilic interactions. As Chris McKay of NASAs Ames Research Center said throughout the press conference, “Part of me hopes that, when we do find life somewhere else, its actually, truly various.”
Nature Astronomy, 2021. DOI: 10.1038/ s41550-021-01391-3(About DOIs).

In 2015, a study made waves by recommending a chemical that had actually been proposed as a possible indication of life was present in the atmosphere of Venus. While the hellish conditions on the planets surface preclude the existence of any sort of life there, it stayed possible that a milder environment existed in the planets clouds, high above its surface. The prospect that the chemical was showing life couldnt be instantly marked down.
In the months following, other researchers cast doubt on the claim that the chemical existed at all. And today, a paper is being launched the suggests that the conditions in Venus clouds are in no way suitable with life even from another location comparable to that on Earth. Although the temperature levels in the clouds are undoubtedly milder, theres nowhere near sufficient water to support life, and the majority of whats present is in beads that are primarily made up of sulfuric acid.
Setting limits
In a press conference announcing the results, John Hallsworth of Queens University Belfast said that the new work was inspired by the evident detection of phosphine in Venus environment. He and his collaborators realized that 2 locations of research had actually combined to create other methods to examine the prospects of life on Venus. One was a research study of life in extreme conditions on Earth, driven in part by a NASA effort to figure out how best to safeguard Mars from contamination by the probes we were sending out there.
The second was likewise NASA-driven: we d sent probes into the atmospheres of some worlds and imaged others. While these probes didnt particularly try to find life, they offered direct measurements of things like temperature and pressure, which set limits on things like the quantity of water present in the atmosphere, and the form that it will adopt.
Appropriate to Venus, individuals have identified organisms that can preserve a metabolism within numerous limitations: temperature level, water, and level of acidity content. Because temperature level modifications with altitude, the previous sets limits on what elevations can be thought about. The latter two are relevant because Venus is believed to be a really dry world, and its clouds are generated not by condensed water however rather by the presence of sulfuric acid droplets that would contain some water.
Advertisement

Scientists measure the quantity of readily available water through a step called the water activity. In easy conditions like a damp environment, this is the exact same as the relative humidity– the quantity of water present versus the optimum quantity at that temperature level and pressure.
For the acid extreme, there is a microorganism that makes it through down to a pH of -0.06, which is the equivalent of having sulfuric acid represent a bit over 10 percent of the weight of its service (with the rest being water).
Not all clouds bring rain
Applying that info to the conditions on Venus yields grim results. Based on measurements from its atmosphere, the researchers determine that Venus relative humidity would be below 0.4 percent– over 100 times lower than the record low tolerated by an organism on Earth.
If you presume that Venusian life could have developed methods of pulling water out of the sporadic atmosphere, then the sulfuric acid becomes a huge issue. The scientists compute that the droplets that form around sulfuric acid would have so little water that concentration by weight of sulfuric acid would be 78 percent– at a minimum. The droplets would max out as almost pure sulfuric acid with a little bit of water.
At that point, the level of acidity of the sulfuric acid is less of a concern than its ability to chemically deteriorate molecules in order to form brand-new water molecules to dissolve in. A graphic presentation of this procedure is offered in this video, which reveals sugar transforming into pure carbon when the water is stripped out of it. The authors of the paper list all of the problems it produces: “Sulfuric acid dehydrates the cellular systems, eliminates water from biomacromolecules, lowers hydrophobic interactions, and damages plasma-membrane stability.”
With Venus ruled out, the scientists turn their attention to in other places in the Solar System. Mars clouds are at temperature levels well below the point where metabolic process shut down completely in the world, based upon measurements made by probes that have actually gone through its environment. Any water present is ice that, for great procedure, is bombarded with sufficient UV radiation to sanitize it. Mars clouds are ruled out.
Advertisement

Enlarge/ Venus thick atmosphere was photographed in ultraviolet light in 1979 by the Pioneer Venus Orbiter.